How to Make the Most Awesome Potato Salad
By Pam Pounds
Step-by-Step Recipe
It took years of honing this family recipe, a favorite made popular by one of my aunts. Now, I think I have finally got it down. Every time I bring this dish to a potluck or family gathering, or just make it for the first time for a new friend, I get raves.
My aunt's version included about a teaspoon of sugar, which I chose to eliminate in favor of a salad with more of a "bite" to it. This recipe is made the way my family prefers it, but you can make it as creamy or not as creamy as you like. As spicy or not as spicy as you like.
Remember to taste as you go.
So, against my youngest daughter's wishes to keep this "our family secret recipe", here is how to make my family-famous potato salad.
Gather the Ingredients
Serves four with leftovers
- 2 lbs. white or red rose potatoes
- 5 hard boiled eggs
- 4 stalks of green onions
- 2 celery stalks (closer to the heart)
- 3/4 cup mayonnaise
- 1 cup sour cream
- 8 to 10 shakes of Tapatio sauce (not Tabasco)
- salt and pepper to taste
- paprika
Cube the Potatoes into Small Bite-Size Pieces
Add the Tapatio for Some Spice
Put It All Together
- Cook the potatoes with the skin on until done. When they are cool enough to touch, peel and cut them into cubes. Put into a large bowl.
- Chop up the green onions and celery. I like the celery to be chopped into a smaller dice, not sliced. Add to the potatoes.
- Cook the eggs until done. Reserve 1 hard boiled egg. Peel and chop 4 of the eggs and add to the salad.
- Add the mayonnaise and sour cream.
- Mix well.
- Add several shakes of the hot pepper sauce.
- Mix it all up. If you like a creamier texture, add more mayo and/or sour cream. If you like a dryer texture, just add less.
- Salt and pepper to taste.
- Place the salad in a serving bowl.
- Slice the remaining egg with an egg slicer and arrange them around the top of the salad.
- Sprinkle some paprika over the top to give it a little color and added spice boost.
- Cover and refrigerate. Serve cold.
Make Awesome Macaroni Salad the Same Way! - All you have to do is substitute elbow macaroni for the potatoes.
Difference Between Tapatio and Tabasco Sauces
Tapatio is a liquid hot pepper sauce that is a slightly thicker consistency than Tabasco. In my opinion, Tapatio has more of a savory and flavorful taste that is spicy without too much heat.
My Secret Ingredient
Link to Tapatio Web Site
- Tapatio Hot Sauce
Find great tasting recipes, learn about our history, purchase Tapatio Hot Sauce, gifts and other products, and ship worldwide at our online store.
Comments
I'm always on the look out for new ideas such as this. Will definitely give this delicious sounding salad a try.
Thanks for the comment, Tom...but, "history of mankind"?? Doubtful, but I'm flattered!
Look, I am the neighbor and this is thee best potato salad ever known in the history of mankind; even better than my mothers and my spouse, but don’t tell her that. Pam, tell the “Beacher” she needs to chill and share. Soon, I will have to start paying for the little tiny minuscule portion that I am portioned to have. But, then there is the marketing I will do for free!!!
Thanks Marisue! I hope you love it! The hot sauce gives it a nice little tinge of color AND flavor...all I can say while you make this, is...taste, taste, taste! A recipe is only as good as the people who eat the end result! I hope you will let me know how it goes.
simple but sounds delicious -- I will try this one. the hot sauce I bet makes this special!! YUM =)



lilypjmom2122 21 months ago
sounds great and delicious! thanks for the info:)